Is India Undercounting Its COVID-19 Dead?
2020-09-20
LRC
TXT
大字
小字
滚动
全页
1Narayan Mitra died on July 16 in India's northeastern Assam state.
2His death came one day after going to the hospital with a high temperature and breathing difficulties.
3Test results later showed that Mitra had been infected with the coronavirus.
4But his name never appeared on any of the official lists of those killed by the coronavirus.
5Doctors said the virus was an "incidental" influence on his death.
6They said his death was caused by a neurological disorder.
7The Associated Press reports that India's national government has asked states not to say an underlying condition caused a patient's death in cases where COVID-19 has been confirmed by tests.
8India has recorded more than 5.1 million COVID-19 infections.
9That is ahead of all other countries except the United States.
10It has recorded more than 83,000 COVID-related deaths.
11That is lower than expected considering its number of infections.
12India's Health Ministry said this is evidence of its success in fighting the coronavirus.
13It has also said the low number of deaths is a reason for easing restrictions and reopening the economy.
14Prime Minister Narendra Modi ordered a nationwide lockdown in March.
15But some experts say the numbers are misleading and that India is not counting many deaths.
16"We are undercounting deaths by an unknown factor," said Dr. T. Jacob John, a retired virus expert.
17The Health Ministry has dismissed earlier accusations that it undercounts deaths.
18But it refused to comment this week on whether states were reporting all suspected and confirmed deaths from the virus.
19Dr. Prabhat Jha is a disease expert at the University of Toronto in Canada.
20He said countries should overestimate death numbers -- not underestimate them -- if they want to make progress in fighting the virus.
21"It is better to have no estimate than an underestimate," Jha said.
22India's Health Ministry recommends that states record all suspected virus deaths.
23That includes cases were the patient likely died of COVID-19 but was not tested for it.
24But these are only guidelines and many states are not following them.
25Mahrashtra is India's worst affected state, with more than 1 million cases.
26There, suspected deaths are not recorded, said the state's health director Dr. Archana Patil.
27Other states, like Assam, have created groups of doctors who separate "real virus deaths" from those caused by underlying diseases.
28In some cities, like New Delhi or Mumbai, these doctor groups sometimes add missed deaths to the count.
29Dr. Anup Kumar Barman heads the doctor group in Assam.
30He said Assam state is not including many deaths where the virus is listed as "incidental" and not the cause of death.
31Assam state has recorded over 147,000 infections but fewer than 500 deaths.
32Those numbers are current as of September 16.
33In Mitra's case, he had more signs of his neurological disorder, Barman said.
34He added that Assam state was following the national guidelines.
35Mitra was not included as a coronavirus victim because his death was not caused by breathing failure, pneumonia or blood clots, Barman added.
36The guidelines list these problems as possible results of the virus, but other problems are possible as well.
37P.V. Ramesh used to lead COVID-19 management for Andhra Pradesh state in southern India.
38He said coronavirus deaths that happen "at home, in transit or while arriving at hospitals don't get counted."
39The low number of reported deaths has resulted in people thinking the virus is not dangerous, said Dr. Anant Bhan, a public health researcher.
40This has led people to not take protective measures such as wearing face coverings or keeping social distance, Bhan said.
41Workers at crematoriums in the country have reported an increase in receiving bodies - whether from the virus or not.
42At a crematorium in the Indian city of Lucknow, worker Bhupesh Soni said 30 bodies were being cremated every day, compared to five or six before the health crisis.
43One cremation normally takes about 45 minutes.
44Soni said there have been days when he has worked for over 20 hours.
45"It is an endless flow of bodies," he said.
46I'm Ashley Thompson.
1Narayan Mitra died on July 16 in India's northeastern Assam state. His death came one day after going to the hospital with a high temperature and breathing difficulties. Test results later showed that Mitra had been infected with the coronavirus. 2But his name never appeared on any of the official lists of those killed by the coronavirus. Doctors said the virus was an "incidental" influence on his death. They said his death was caused by a neurological disorder. 3The Associated Press reports that India's national government has asked states not to say an underlying condition caused a patient's death in cases where COVID-19 has been confirmed by tests. 4India has recorded more than 5.1 million COVID-19 infections. That is ahead of all other countries except the United States. It has recorded more than 83,000 COVID-related deaths. That is lower than expected considering its number of infections. 5India's Health Ministry said this is evidence of its success in fighting the coronavirus. It has also said the low number of deaths is a reason for easing restrictions and reopening the economy. Prime Minister Narendra Modi ordered a nationwide lockdown in March. 6But some experts say the numbers are misleading and that India is not counting many deaths. "We are undercounting deaths by an unknown factor," said Dr. T. Jacob John, a retired virus expert. 7The Health Ministry has dismissed earlier accusations that it undercounts deaths. But it refused to comment this week on whether states were reporting all suspected and confirmed deaths from the virus. 8Dr. Prabhat Jha is a disease expert at the University of Toronto in Canada. He said countries should overestimate death numbers -- not underestimate them -- if they want to make progress in fighting the virus. 9"It is better to have no estimate than an underestimate," Jha said. 10India's Health Ministry recommends that states record all suspected virus deaths. That includes cases were the patient likely died of COVID-19 but was not tested for it. But these are only guidelines and many states are not following them. 11Mahrashtra is India's worst affected state, with more than 1 million cases. There, suspected deaths are not recorded, said the state's health director Dr. Archana Patil. 12Other states, like Assam, have created groups of doctors who separate "real virus deaths" from those caused by underlying diseases. In some cities, like New Delhi or Mumbai, these doctor groups sometimes add missed deaths to the count. 13Dr. Anup Kumar Barman heads the doctor group in Assam. He said Assam state is not including many deaths where the virus is listed as "incidental" and not the cause of death. Assam state has recorded over 147,000 infections but fewer than 500 deaths. Those numbers are current as of September 16. 14In Mitra's case, he had more signs of his neurological disorder, Barman said. He added that Assam state was following the national guidelines. Mitra was not included as a coronavirus victim because his death was not caused by breathing failure, pneumonia or blood clots, Barman added. 15The guidelines list these problems as possible results of the virus, but other problems are possible as well. 16P.V. Ramesh used to lead COVID-19 management for Andhra Pradesh state in southern India. He said coronavirus deaths that happen "at home, in transit or while arriving at hospitals don't get counted." 17The low number of reported deaths has resulted in people thinking the virus is not dangerous, said Dr. Anant Bhan, a public health researcher. This has led people to not take protective measures such as wearing face coverings or keeping social distance, Bhan said. 18Workers at crematoriums in the country have reported an increase in receiving bodies - whether from the virus or not. 19At a crematorium in the Indian city of Lucknow, worker Bhupesh Soni said 30 bodies were being cremated every day, compared to five or six before the health crisis. 20One cremation normally takes about 45 minutes. Soni said there have been days when he has worked for over 20 hours. 21"It is an endless flow of bodies," he said. 22I'm Ashley Thompson. 23Andiruddha Ghosal and Sheikh Salliq reported this story for the Associated Press. Ashley Thompson adapted it for VOA Learning English. Mario Ritter, Jr. was the editor. 24_______________________________________________________ 25Words in This Story 26neurological -adj. related to the nervous system which includes the spinal cord, nerves and the brain 27underlying -adj. something that is the basis or cause of something 28pneumonia -n. a serious infection of the lungs 29(blood) clot -n. blockage or barrier of dried blood that prevents the flow of blood through its passageways in the body 30management -n. overseeing and dealing with the problems of a large task 31transit -n. the act of moving from one place to another 32crematoriums -n. a place where bodies of the dead are turned to ash 33We want to hear from you. Write to us in the Comments section, and visit our Facebook page.